Question:
When making a sandwich or potato salad wich ingredient do you prefer to use I've heard comments about both, I prefer mayo and cant quite grasp why anyone would prefer miracle whip

Choices:
Mayonnaise
Miracle Whip

 

I have ALWAYS been a Miracle Whip kid...got it from my parents I imagine. I just really prefer the bit of zing in MW over Mayo. To me, Mayo tastes like nothing!

Don't worry hon, I'll always have BOTH kinds in the fridge

looks like mayo is in the lead
Giz Honey you have no Idea how happy I am we'll have both in the fridge

This message has been edited. Last edited by: MADMAC,

I grew up with miracle whip, hated the stuff, so the minute I moved out I started buying mayo. Helmans is the best!!!! I do like deviled eggs and tater salad make with miracle whip, it just adds that extra flavor, but as far as on sammiches its mayo all the way

Renee, I'm with you all the way.I tried miracle whip only on sandwiches and didnt like it so I didnt try it after that period, UNTIL....Giz she made some egg salad with miracle whip and I did like the added flavour.
Enjoy and keep Smiling

LOL that giz........she can make anything taste good

I prefer mayo myself over miracle whip. I hate it. it's wretched stuff no matter what it is on/in whatever. Miracle Whip is pure poison.

No offense to all you die hard Miracle whip fans though.

Something kind of funny though on a side note. Back during the whole Y2K scare, my grandmother decided to "stockpile" some food. In a cupboard in the garage, she had several large cans of tuna fish and...severl large jars of...Miracle Whip! (yes, she was a hardcore Miracle Whip fanatic)

Just old fashion I guess

I like both (as long as the mayo is Duke's) but can't imagine why anyone thinks one is a replacement for the other. They are different products altogether! Miracle has both a sweet and sour flavor, while mayo has neither. They are as different as ketchup and mustard, except for a close color resemblance.

Never cared for Miracle Whip.

Mayonnaise always!

And if it's my own homemade blend.....even better. MMMmmmmm........

Mayo for sure!!!!

Fuse, a lot of people don't even know that they are different...I had a friend who claimed to hate tuna, potato, egg salad, etc....anything made with "mayo" he finally tried my mom's potato salad and loved it, we figured out that he thought Miracle Whip was mayo.

quote:

he thought Miracle Whip was mayo.

Someone should have told him Kraft makes both.

And Mayo with a whopping Lead he he honestly I thought Miracle whip was Mayo gone Bad.

quote:

To me, Mayo tastes like nothing!

Mix it with horseradish for more of a pop.

quote:

Originally posted by juanruiz:
Never cared for Miracle Whip.

I really LOVE Miracle Whip

I like them both. I like Miracle whip with sandwiches and i like mayo with potato salad and deviled eggs!

Grew up with Miracle Whip, still use it, always will - don't like change!

In fact 2 nights ago dropped a ginormous jar of it all over my kitchen floor, not a deterrent though, I love and need my Miracle Whip!

I liked MW, until I tried REAL MAYO for the very first time!!!!

Will never use MW again.

I say Whip it... Whip it good. ALways have loved Miracle Whip and it is my only choice.